R4Six
  • R4Six Home
    • No Reservations
    • Top Billin'
    • Top Performers
    • Games of the Week
  • R4Two Hoops
  • The Bird Cage
  • Coop's PSU Review
  • Kentucky HS Varsity
    • South Warren HS, Bowling Green


The Bird
Cage

L1C4

​Louisville Lawyer Files Suit Against Katina Powell on Behalf of UofL Students

10/22/2015

63 Comments

 
Picture
​Louisville Lawyer Sues Katina Powell for UofL Students
by Ambrose O'Bryan

edited by Dave Lackford
​
Louisville lawyer Nader G. Shunnarah has filed a civil suit against Katina Powell and IBJ Publishing on behalf of current University of Louisville students. Shunnarah has also petitioned the Court to obtain an injunction, stopping IBJ from paying Katina Powell from the proceeds of the book. The lawsuit alleges that Powell engaged in criminal conduct, promoting prostitution, and is now profiting from that criminal conduct.

In Kentucky, people who are intentionally harmed by the criminal conduct of someone else have a statutory right to recovery for that harm under KRS 446.070.  That statute says, “A person injured by the violation of any statute may recover from the offender such damages as he sustained by reason of the violation.” Essentially, the claim here is that Katina Powell has harmed students at the University of Louisville because of her criminal acts, and not those students have a right to recover from her.
Think about it like this:
  1. Students at the University of Louisville are there because a degree from UofL has a market value greater than a degree from a smaller school, like Murray or Morehead State. Students also pay a premium price for that degree, more than they would pay for a degree at a smaller school.
  2. The value of that degree is now diminished because the reputation of the school has been forever tarnished due to Katina Powell’s criminal conduct. 
  3. The students who have been harmed by this criminal conduct have a statutory right to recover for that harm.  

It’s a creative legal theory.  It will be very interesting to see if the Court freezes Powell’s proceeds from the book, “Breaking Cardinal Rules.”

In an interview with Reservations4Six, Shunnarah said:

 “The goal here is to benefit students instead of the prostitute.  Who better to benefit than the students?  When you commit a criminal act and it damages an entire University, your degree, the value of your degree, your ability to pay back student loans, and your ability to get a job? What do you think of when you mention Penn State?  If you’ve got a degree from PSU, it’s got that taint to it and that has an effect. Also, if the school is sanctioned by the NCAA and can’t participate in the NCAA tournament, then the school loses money and that effects the students, tuition goes up.”

Currently there is only one student named in the law suit.  Shunnarah invites any currently enrolled University of Louisville Student to join the suit by calling Nader George Shunnarah at 502-587-7919 or by emailing him at [email protected].  
63 Comments
Bill
10/22/2015 15:01:24

The problem here...a university employee, McGee, brought her on campus. Two, your degree hasn't lost value, degrees are and always will be what you make of them. Is the lawsuit claiming no one from a smaller school has ever gotten gainful employment equal to or more than someone at a large school? 3. It would be absurd if every school sued for thimgs related to outsiders. This is an athletic ordeal and has nothing to do with academics, something uofl ppl generally dont realize....your a school first This is an attempt to make this go away...it will not.

Reply
Jimmy Russel
10/22/2015 15:49:58

>degree is what you make of it
Lol yeah man I'll just tell my potential employers to consider my degree to basically be a Harvard degree. I'm sure they'll understand.

Reply
Mike link
10/22/2015 16:57:53

I agree with Bill. The approach is an attempt to punish the punisher. Someone opened the floodgate by bringing the woman on campus in the first place. "Tit-4-tat" is not a good strategy. It can't be.

Reply
Susan
10/22/2015 17:11:07

"Someone from the University brought her on campus"?? Or did she arrive by her own means? She is an adult, although not a very bright one, she made her own decisions. I have not heard of her being forced into any of this. She needs to be held accountable!

Biggame
10/22/2015 18:17:02

Sounds like a true UK Fan

Reply
Matt
10/22/2015 18:54:03

D'oh! You got all the way to the end about how the point of college is education and dropped the ball. "Your" school would be sad to see how "you're" writing here.

Reply
D
10/22/2015 19:03:37

It looks like you could stand to get an education with your poor use of grammar but...

Reply
Jeremy
10/22/2015 20:01:46

Ha, uk fan trolling.

Reply
Sarah
10/22/2015 22:33:37

Bill, there has been no actual proof of anything. This woman supposedly slept with teenage boys for money. .. not only does that completely diminish her ability to appear as a valid source, but it also makes her a criminal. You are wrong. Degrees aren't just degrees. You must be a uk fan

Reply
KJH
10/22/2015 23:03:32

YOU'RE

Reply
Sondra
10/22/2015 23:37:59

'your're a school first' as in you are.

Reply
Frank
10/23/2015 10:00:24

I am not sure this suit is a good thing, but looking at it from the point that this prostitute should NOT be able to get rich for writing a book about what she did illegally. The UL person who brought her on campus is not benefiting financially from the book, but neither should she! She definitely should not gain from these actions! Anyone who can find a way to stop that from happening, then I would have to be on their side. Better the students of UL get the money than the prostitute!

Reply
Eddie
10/22/2015 15:27:08

So is the lawsuit going to sue the players too? Not only is prostitution illegal...soliciting it is as well. Only blaming Katina reinforces uofls perceived culture of a war on women.

Reply
Bobbie
10/23/2015 03:31:13

She wasn't solicited by the players,but by the recruiter.She also admitted that she supplied the liquor ,those boys were underage.

Reply
Shorty Blue
10/22/2015 15:29:34

Shouldnt McGee and the UofL basketball program be sued as well for turning Minardi Hall into a strip club and brothel?

Reply
Ant
10/22/2015 15:29:56

We get it. People in Louisvile hate women. Good luck filth.

Reply
Sam.
10/22/2015 15:43:07

It's spelled "Louisville". Comments with misspelled words lose credibility. Sorry.

Reply
Burfer
10/22/2015 15:53:40

Pretty sure the misspelling was intentional.

Shorty Blue
10/22/2015 16:04:27

Sam is a little slow

Bobbie
10/23/2015 03:50:14

Ant ,no we don't hate women,what we hate is being dragged I the spotlight by anyone's greed.We don't hate Katina
,well I don't hate her ,oh I am female 60 years .I am the mother of 4 girls ,and I have granddaughters .Her sister said she had to TRICK so she could take care of her children,how about getting a real job,and before you comment I've been a nurse now 38 years.And to top that off after she "raised her girls she turned then in h$$$ as well .Oh Inwill go on,then for some reason Andre (maybe )decided to use her as a recruiting tool
.ARE YOU KIDDING ME.anyway,as Andre was transitioning to Missouri ,her services were no longer needed or wanted ,I guess? So Madame became angry.The money dried up,angrier still .Then to top the whole foolery the NCAA snubbed Madame.So no we don't hate women.And not only is this mess casting a bad light of the univ,those were children she was turning out.Im sure someone was 17.Shevposted their name in her crappy book,why is she trying to ruin them ,she is hateful ,vengeaful and broke.

Reply
Khalid A Ali
10/22/2015 15:30:18

I back you up 100℅ I think that this is and act totally to #1Get paid & set up UofL to get more money out of them her meal ticket left UofL I think she tried to get more money and wasn't able to #2 Indiana never had a lost for love with UofL they're down a been on the road of just being and OK basketball program in the world recruitment and black eye on a near but major power who has the only D1 basketball program in the country the brings in more money than its football program recruitment opportunities then come to your favor think about when was the last time IU really been talked about as a national championship contender their black eye was Bobby Knight leaving them they really haven't been a competitor since once a black eye is placed on your program it's a long time before you can recover #3 well done IU you took on a chance to destroy the future of some kids because no one else would pay attention to include the NCAA to a female cause she's definitely not a woman or a mother as far as that is concern who's nasty no count behind pimped her own Daughters which the last time I checked is illegal and if they were under age at that time you're talking about then a rape case which she knew all this time it was a set up from the beginning she gets paid one way or the other and her lawyer want to strike a deal so that her good for nothing ass won't go to jail I SAY HELL NO PUT HER ASS IN JAIL Then she can trick see wants

Reply
Hoosier
10/22/2015 15:47:22

Very well thought out comments, Khalid. Blaming IU rather than the whore loving UL players makes a lot of sense.

By the way, last time I checked, Indiana has 5 titles, and UL has 3 (for now). If Indiana is "just okay", that makes your team even less.

Duh.

Reply
B
10/22/2015 18:24:07

Lol IU is "just ok". Tell me, when was your last national championship? Matter of fact, IU has been "just ok" for so long now they have began to hang up sweet sixteen banners...and handing out sweet 16 rings..

amanda
10/22/2015 18:34:32

If you put her in jail then McGee needs to be in jail to. He is just as guilty.

Reply
Matt
10/22/2015 18:36:15

IU's 2012-2013 team was the pre season number 1 ranked team they spent 10 weeks ranked # 1 they beat KY they got beat by Syracuse who made it to the final four. And Syracuse is now known as cheaters. IU went to the final game in the 2001-2002 they beat Duke and Uconn I believe to get to the final game I think they lost to UMASS.Both after knight they where projected to do well under Sampson but he was a cheater before he got there and is the reason IU had to rebuild

Reply
Lisa
10/22/2015 15:32:49

The Sports Illustrated article headline was "The University of Louisville creates a culture of violence against women." It did not read "The University of Louisville Basketball Team." For example the Duke Lacrosse scandal was always referred to as Duke Lacrosse not just Duke.

That implies that the entire university is unsafe and I would not send my children to a place that isn't safe. That article was a direct result of Katina Powell's actions to "bring down" the school. Those were her own words. She is the one who has brought the entire university faculty, students, staff and alumni into it. She did not make this about her and McGhee or the Basketball team. She could contacted the school, U of L is the one that initiated the NCAA investigation after they found out about it and she admits that she and the publisher refused to cooperate and provide the School with the allegations but told them to "buy the book". So now the school is belittled nationally because of her and the publisher.

The school would have initiated the investigation if she told them and it would have made the news in a different way. She claims she contacted the NCAA but they have a protocol for filing complaints and she did not follow that. She decided to "take them down".

So that is what I think they are referring to. And people do look at the school you graduated from and not just the degree. A Harvard Degree has more weight than a degree from Spalding. The name of the school definitely matters.

I agree it that they may not get paid. I also do not think this is an attempt to make it go away but to make Katina Powell deal with the some of the stress she caused others. And as of right now it has to be proven that McGhee brought her there. The investigation is not over and nothing involving him has been proven yet it is just alleged.

As of right now she has admitted to bringing criminal activity to the University and her daughters admitted it too. So I think this is more "she is wasting our time so we can waste hers" and she should not profit from promoting prostitution. So at the least they are hoping she doesn't continue to get paid for this book.

We all know the investigation is happening and I think we all want the truth and want to wait for the results from both criminal investigations and the joint NCAA/ University investigation which will take a while. We know that is not going away and I don't want it to. I want the real facts from the hired professionals and that will take time.

Reply
Lol
10/22/2015 17:07:00

Like you need this incident to warn you that Louisville is unsafe?
What about the time when a UofL Cheerleader was found dead in a college dorm room due to a drug overdose (but no one knows from which drug because of how many were in her system). The cheer coaches know and participate in the drug use with their athletes. That right there is a red flag (to me) that Louisville is unsafe.

Reply
joeB
10/22/2015 17:31:20

You're dumb.
10/22/2015 19:05:23

To "lol".

The diagnoses of the drug overdose was declared a lethal amount of heroin. Do your research retard. Someone died because of poor choices they made. Our dance team is the best team in the nation almost every year. They are the most attractive and well proportioned also they have NO recorded issues with male interactions that are disrepectful or unwanted.. Sounds like you need to get off your couch in Lexington and stay away from a post about a school that you don't know anything about. Peace

Bert
10/22/2015 19:51:19

Lol, why can't you put your name on here if you're gonna make slandering remarks. I suggest you edit your remark or maybe you'll be next in lawsuit

Chris
10/22/2015 15:38:33

Is Andre McGee earning income from this? Are the players? Is UofL? You are missing the point. The attorney is not saying that U of l, Andre or the players are not wrong for what happened. He is saying she is wrong for profiting from her acts.

Reply
Liz
10/22/2015 18:26:00

I think that they will have a lot on their hands with burden of proof... prostitution is illegal but it was the book that created the scandal... so is the book illegal? Also will need irrefutable proof that the u of l name is objectively tarnished across the board. Furthermore someone could argue that yes the team and McGee profited from the prostitution because using such a bribe they were able to secure better players, get more wins, etc. It is all going to boil down to who has the best lawyer here. But the one filing suit is smart... high profile case = big time notoriety. Great marketing.

Reply
Amanda
10/22/2015 18:42:31

Wrong for profiting from her acts? How many murderers profit from books about them selves? Whether it be from money or fame? What she did is wrong, what the players did is wrong, should she make money from it? No, but neither should they!

Reply
Regina
10/24/2015 08:57:23

There is an actual law that about criminals profit time g from books about their victims. It was national news for months when OK wrote his book "imagining" how Nicole was killed.

Gary
10/22/2015 15:55:50

loser uk fans are so easy to peg. LMAO

Reply
Tracie
10/22/2015 16:39:00

Well I'm a UK fan...and not a loser I might add. I don't agree with all the others. That woman should be sued and should NOT in any way profit from this book. I don't understand them questioning whether or not the players, McGee and the university will be sued. McGee and any other "leader" in that school that had anything to do with this will probably lose their job...and should lose their job if it's found they are guilty. They are not the ones that will profit from this book...Powell is. She is going to make money from a book telling of how she exploited her children. Not only should she not profit from the sale of the book, she should go to prison with the other child abusers and sexual predators.

Reply
Amanda
10/22/2015 18:44:29

They were 16! it was their choice! They even said it was their choice.

Me
10/22/2015 23:41:38

Go girl

Steve
10/22/2015 16:11:04

Murray St and Morehead students should sue this lawyer for defaming their degree. All NCAA affiliated Basketball Schools should sue UL since they are responsible for tarnishing the integrity of the sport for all.
The time is now for all lawyers to reap the opportunities created by this scandal.

Reply
Badcat555
10/22/2015 19:44:44

I totally agree Steve. My daughter will Graduate in the spring with a BS in Nursing from Morehead State and I think she would have a good case against this Lawyer for belittling her degree. She will be in search of a job in the Spring and this article could hurt her chances of getting a job over a UL student. Let the Law suits begin!

Reply
Shorty Blue
10/22/2015 16:11:21

I guess when your program is gonna up in flames the only thing that can make you feel better is to sue the person that is profiting from it. I would be embarrassed to have my name on that suit.

Reply
ULL
10/22/2015 16:34:27

Did you graduate from UK, or are you just one of their many, many die-hard fans that didn't graduate from anywhere? Why would students be embarrassed to join a lawsuit against someone whose criminal actions are affecting their school's credibility? Spoiler alert, they wouldn't, go troll KSR.

Reply
Blah
10/22/2015 18:20:51

Louisville is trash, just stroll past campus, your in the ghetto

Stevie Wonder
10/22/2015 16:33:54

Can Michigan State fans sue the punter for losing to Michigan. Lots of mental anguish for the fans. This and Louisville is a JOKE!

Reply
Shorty Blue
10/22/2015 16:43:49

So, I guess this lawsuit means that the crimes actually took place, and UofL ran a brothel to get players to commit and there is now a huge asterisk on the 2013 banner. You guys must be so proud

Reply
D
10/22/2015 19:08:32

No....it means her allegations have tarnished the reputation. Reading comprehension is such a valuable tool 😉

Reply
Pitino's Bookie
10/22/2015 16:53:54

This is just another attempt at deflecting. The issue isn't about UL students being effected......it's about revenge from former alumni. If her accusations were fiction and false then they have a case for defamation. However her story and claims are a direct reflection of events and actions that she experience and she has the freedom to communicate them in any manner she chooses under the 1st Amendment of the Constitution.
This is without a doubt, is going to be thrown out in court.

This guy along with any other butt hurt alumni, should be suing the coaches that caused this mess.
However we all know that, it will never happen. Lol

Reply
Try Again
10/23/2015 08:21:42

Freedom of speech is pointless when you're breaking the law (prostitution) and intentionally damaging the reputation of an academic institution in the process. It's not a defamation case (read again, more carefully this time) The real deflection here is you trying to spin this to your own agenda: discredit Pitino and/or UofL staff.

Reply
Jeff
10/22/2015 16:56:38

This is about a lawyer trying to cash in.

Reply
Chip
10/22/2015 17:01:01

Andre Mcgee, UofL, and Pitino are already paying the price and, assuming the facts back it up, will be paying a HUGE monetary and personal price for their misdeeds. This is as it should be.

Those who think this woman should profit from child trafficking with her daughters are insane!! I hope & pray SHE has to pay the piper as well! It's just plain sick to sell your offspring's bodies whether or not they were of legal age (barely, maybe)!!

Reply
Vicki
10/22/2015 17:21:34

Is this a lawyer hired by the U of L? Is this just some crap for a lawyer to have a chance of getting money for themselves?

Reply
Try Reading
10/23/2015 08:00:24

No, the lawyer is acting on behalf of the UofL student body. The main motive is to cut off the whore's income from book sales, not make money off of the civil suit.

Reply
Dave
10/22/2015 18:19:18

How could a current student place a value on a degree that they have not yet obtained? Seems like this would be for alumni that hold a degree from U of L.

Reply
Brittney
10/22/2015 21:57:12

That's what I was thinking. Current alumni would be the ones affected.

Reply
Marty
10/22/2015 18:50:07

I would think the goal of this suit is actually to force the author to swear in court under oath that what she wrote is true. And that would be an admission of guilt to multiple crimes, including prostitution of minors.

Reply
Jota
10/23/2015 07:03:52

I would think the goal of this lawsuit is for Shunnarah to get paid. Is he providing his class action services pro bono?

Reply
Cardinal fan
10/22/2015 19:01:07

Ok for real, Katina DID solicit her children out sexually...for money. Any way you squeeze it. Prostitution. Doesn't matter wether she started it or not. Yes! She needs to face criminal charges.. But also. Those others who are guilty. Even if that means former players or recruits.. Or PARENTS of recruits. They all need to face crinkle charges. The university isn't IU. We will rebuttal from this well. IU and Tommy "can't coach". Shouldn't ever be in this convo...

For the people who are talking about how many titles we have compared to the ones IU has.. You're an idiot. This conversation isn't about comparing the two schools and their prestigious acheivements.. Because let's keep it real. IU can't and will never be as prestigious as Louisville. Sorry about ya.

Reply
Totalyscrewedup
10/22/2015 23:13:39

As far as I know, Kentucky law isn't same as Nevada law. Therefore, prostitution is still illegal in Kentucky. Regardless of your opinion about U of L, Petino or the decisions that are about to be made by NCAA or the lawsuit itself, the law itself states that this is a felony during which all profits made by the perpetrator(s) (the prostitutes and the madam), are illegally obtained and therfore forfeit

Reply
ULEMPLOYEE
10/23/2015 02:41:36

Include the staff in the cival action. ULAA often makes donations to general fund to help provide raises for staff. With state funding diminished these monies and private donations are the nucleus of university finances. These charges surely will hamper both.

Reply
Sparky
10/23/2015 05:12:20

How did the prostitutes get in Menardi Hall without having assistance????? And I believe Pitino knows everything that happens in Menardi Hall. If he doesn't.....he is paid too much. Oh I forgot, he is paid too much anyway.

Reply
Alan
10/23/2015 07:02:33

Seems to me that both parties were performing illegal acts. Not only were basketball players getting improper benefits, they were also breaking the law. Sounds like a vacated championship to me.

Reply
Try Reading
10/23/2015 08:05:45

Both parties? The only parties involved in this lawsuit are UofL students, Katina Powell and IBJ. If you want to jibber jabber about the truth of allegations and their ramifications on UofL athletics, do it somewhere else.

Reply
Shorty Blue
10/23/2015 09:40:09

Alan, give up, these guys have gone full blown delusional. You cant argue with an insane person. Its sad, you would think grown ups would just say "Wow, we messed up, lets take our medicine and move own".

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OcWFuzptMSs


True Statement: The value of her degree was damaged more severely by the grammar illustrated in Behanan's and TWill's comments than anything else.




Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015

    @Onest_abe

    Abe is R4six's Louisville Cardinals writer. 
    Follow him on twitter.

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Subscribe

Join our mailing list today!

Submit
Join Now
  • R4Six Home
    • No Reservations
    • Top Billin'
    • Top Performers
    • Games of the Week
  • R4Two Hoops
  • The Bird Cage
  • Coop's PSU Review
  • Kentucky HS Varsity
    • South Warren HS, Bowling Green
✕